I saw Infamous this weekend. The Variety review was right. It’s lighter and funnier than Capote, less perfect, with a much more homoerotic take on the Truman-Perry relationship.
Infamous didn’t grab me viscerally and throw me from the train like Capote did. One reason for that, I think, is that Douglas McGrath (screenwriter, director) didn’t show rather than merely have his characters talk about the long, pathetic deflation Capote suffered after In Cold Blood came out.
The stage is set. We’ve met all the ‘interesting’ socialites who lapped up the author’s buoyant dog and pony show. Until finally they realized that they were the dogs and the ponies in the long-awaited follow-up, and that the unfinished book about them wasn’t even any good. Which is worse? Death by hanging or death by despair?
I wonder whether both directors shied away from such a coda — Fat Truman — because it would have meant not only turning the knife in their subject’s back but also splattering his blood all over the socialites, some of whom must, presumably, still be with us?
Or maybe they just had the same idea: that what really mattered in Capote’s life is contained within the making of his seminal book, because the book told us so much about ourselves. About the voyeuristic sadism at our core, about our complicated relationship with the truth. How we gasp when the words ‘based on a true story’ appear at the end of a gripping film! How we sniff when the truth isn’t entertaining enough!
If you can stand to watch this entertaining but (in light of its predecessor) not terribly gripping film, you’ll be rewarded with a game of spot-the-difference. Here are two movies based on a true story (about the making of a true story), and yet their versions of the same story hold hundreds of devilishly different details. The fabulist is not more real to us at the end but more fabulous. Just as he would have wanted it.
Besides, if you’re going to have breakfast at Tiffany’s, the truth isn’t the necklaces or even the diamonds set within them. The truth is the way the light plays off the gems’ facets.
Image: Truman behind glass (on the wall near my desk).












